Find BC Parent

Pandemic Parenting: What Happens If We Can’t Agree On Whether Or Not To Vaccinate Our Child?

Pandemic Parenting: What Happens If We Can’t Agree On Whether Or Not To Vaccinate Our Child?

pandemic
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on whatsapp
Reading Time: 4 minutes

The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has forced parents to make a number of challenging decisions, and most recently, the predicament as to whether or not they should vaccinate their child. These decisions become more difficult still when it comes to parents who share the duties and responsibilities of raising their child though they are separated or divorced, and no longer live together.

As of November 19th, Health Canada has authorized the use of the Pfizer vaccine for children between the ages of 5 to 11. The BC Centre for Disease Control (the “BCCDC”) has since recommended that parents do vaccinate their children against the COVID-19 virus.

The court’s only consideration in matters involving children is “What is in the best interest of the child?”. In this regard, Canadian courts have almost universally favoured permitting the vaccination of the child.

Even before a COVID-19 vaccine was approved for use in Canada, the Ontario Court of Justice in Tarkowski v. Lemieux, 2020 ONCJ 280 gave a father the authority to vaccinate his 7-year old daughter. In this case, the mother was opposed to vaccines in general and had also initially refused consent to the child being immunized as an infant.

Fast forward to this summer when the vaccine became available for children aged 12 and up, the Queen’s Bench for Saskatchewan in O.M.S. v. E.J.S., 2021 SKQB 243 ordered that a 12-year old child be vaccinated against COVID-19 despite the child’s wish not to be vaccinated and a diagnosis of “possible” vaccine toxicity. The father sought to have his daughter vaccinated, but the mother vehemently opposed it.

Both of the parents in this case brought extensive medical evidence. In support of vaccination, the father brought evidence from an infectious disease physician, an assistant professor who is also a Canada Research Chair in emerging viruses in the Department of Medical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases at the University of Manitoba, as well as the child’s family physician since their daughter’s birth.

In opposition, the mother brought forward evidence from a family physician from another province that indicated he has a special interest in vaccines and is opposed to vaccinations with Pfizer, as well as an anesthesiologist and previously tenured professor regarding a “possible” vaccine toxicity diagnosis. While the court preferred the father’s expert evidence, the court did not rely on it.

Ultimately, the court’s decision relied on the facts that did not require evidence, as they were found to be “so notorious as not to be the subject of dispute among reasonable people”.

Consequently, the court refused to consider arguments relating to the legitimacy of the pandemic, the government’s response, and the safety or efficacy of vaccines approved by Health Canada. Instead, the court considered only what was in the best interest of the child, determined by factors such as the child’s needs, views or desires.

In this case, the child’s wish not to be vaccinated was considered but given little weight since the court was concerned that the child’s position was influenced by others. The court rejected the argument that the child’s needs were impacted by a medical diagnosis of “possible” vaccine toxicity. The visiting physician’s diagnosis was not definitive and was based on incomplete medical information.

The court held that it was in the child’s best interest to avoid contracting the virus, and that the most efficacious defense against contracting COVID-19 at this time is through vaccination.

Although BC courts have not yet weighed in on COVID-19 vaccines for children, they have consistently provided the pro-vaccine parent with the authority to make decisions about vaccinating the child in accordance with Public Health Department and Health Authority recommendations.

In both M.J.T. v. D.M.D., 2012 BCSC 863 and G.M. v. S.S., 2012 BCSC 1491, the Supreme Court of BC authorized the father to vaccinate his preschooler, despite the mother’s belief that pediatric vaccines contribute to autism in children. In these two cases, the court preferred medical evidence that demonstrated how the benefits of immunization for the child outweighed any risk of side effects.

In conclusion, each of these cases demonstrate that the vaccines approved by Health Canada and that are recommended by health authorities will almost universally be in the best interest of a child. Now that the Pfizer vaccine has been approved for younger children, paired with the BCCDC’s recommendation that parents vaccinate their children to keep them safe, co-parents in BC should be prepared for courts to conclude that vaccination is in the best interest of their child.

Author Bio

Chantal Cattermole is a senior partner at Clark Wilson LLP and co-chair to the firm’s Family Law practice.

Follow:

Trending

playdough

Rainy day activity – yummy, scented playdough!

6 Reasons Your Child Might Need Physiotherapy That Is Commonly Missed

BC Parent NewsMagazine Logo | www.bcparent.ca | BC Parent Logo

A quest for sleep – my sleep training diaries

children's Festival

2022 Vancouver International Children’s Festival

dental

Teach Your Kids the Importance of Dental Health With These 5 Activities 

Environment Spring Cleaning

5 Amazing Environmentally Friendly Tips for a More Sustainable Spring Cleaning Season

Related Posts

dental
Teach Your Kids the Importance of Dental Health With These 5 Activities 

Reading Time: 6 minutes
At a young age, the little ones are not too conscious about their dental health. They resist toothbrushing, fear the dentist, and love sweets. These things can contribute to life-long problems, which could have been easily avoided if parents are more mindful.
Here are some of the best activities that can teach kids the importance of dental health. Start them young, and for sure, they will pick up good habits that they will be thankful for when they grow up.

Environment Spring Cleaning
5 Amazing Environmentally Friendly Tips for a More Sustainable Spring Cleaning Season

Reading Time: 4 minutes
have a duty to protect the environment, but over half (52%) don’t know where to start*. A simple way to step-up sustainability at home is with some eco-friendly spring-cleaning hacks.

meditation
Powerful Meditation - Becoming Wholeheartedly Ourselves

Reading Time: 10 minutes
Meditation - By learning to observe the changing nature of our mind and body we have the potential to gain a profound and life-changing self-knowledge, a deep inner knowing that can lead to enduring peace. Is facing the unruly mind sometimes daunting? Yes. But in time we begin to see the impermanent flow of thought, emotion, sensation, and the unfolding of our lives with greater compassion and a little more humor. We tend to take our human predicament very seriously at times!

Lump
LUMP Reminds Women to Check for Lumps This Mother’s Day

Reading Time: 3 minutes
LUMP Foundation, a new Vancouver-based non-profit, has invented a novel way of empowering women and reminding everyone about the lifesaving importance of early breast cancer detection. In recognition of Mother’s Day, LUMP has created a limited edition, bouclé blend pillow in the prettiest pink, reminiscent of fluffy Spring cherry blossoms. It will only be available from April 14th to May 8th at www.lump.live/ - just in time for Mother's Day giving.

Scroll to Top

Connect with us

Signup today for the latest parenting tips, contest alerts and local deals.

BC Parent Cookies | www.bcparent.ca | BC Parent

We care about your data, and we'd love to use cookies to make your experience better